top of page

By: Yasmine Jacobs

Many complain about government: what it does, what it doesn’t do and how much money it spends… the list goes on. But what would happen if we took away government rule? Don’t rejoice just yet. Read carefully what I am about to tell you and then answer the question: would you rather live in anarchistic Kowloon with terrible living conditions or live comfortably under government rule?

Once upon a time in Kowloon

With 50 000 residents, Kowloon Walled City in Hong Kong was said to be the world’s most densely populated place. It was the home of drug lords, criminals, prostitutes and gangsters (I know you said ‘gangsta’, it’s gangster in this case). Kowloon was also anarchistic, which means they were not under government rule. In 1948, there was a failed attempt to drive out the squatters in Kowloon and the British resorted to a ‘hands-off’ policy concerning the Walled City. From the 1950s to the 1970s, the Chinese Triads ruled and, in 1993, the City was demolished. It might seem intimidating and frightening, but people continued to live ‘comfortable’ lives.

 

You are probably thinking: “How the hell can you live a happy life in a place like that?” It’s simple. If you grow up in a certain community, you grow accustomed to its way of living and eventually pick up the community’s habits. You begin to see it as ‘normal’. It’s only when you are made aware of other ways of life that you start comparing and say, “Oh, if only we were like so-and-so.” But what if the residents of Kowloon did not worry about other people? There were possibly many reasons for their happiness, but because they were somewhat ‘disconnected’ from the rest of the world they had nothing with which to compare their lifestyles. We also need to remember that that was their home. It was where they were born and bred and had memories. So yes, they might have been poor but they were happy.

You are probably thinking: “How the hell can you live a happy life in a place like that?” It’s simple. If you grow up in a certain community, you grow accustomed to its way of living and eventually pick up the community’s habits. You begin to see it as ‘normal’. It’s only when you are made aware of other ways of life that you start comparing and say, “Oh, if only we were like so-and-so.” But what if the residents of Kowloon did not worry about other people? There were possibly many reasons for their happiness, but because they were somewhat ‘disconnected’ from the rest of the world they had nothing with which to compare their lifestyles. We also need to remember that that was their home. It was where they were born and bred and had memories. So yes, they might have been poor but they were happy.

 

Now let’s take a look at our world. Unlike Kowloon, our houses are not on top of each other. We have clean running water and municipal services. Because of the ‘hands-off’ policy, there were no municipal services in Kowloon so rubbish piled up without a refuse removal truck coming every week. The sizes of the houses in our communities vary, whereas Kowloon was one large flat. The size of one’s house (or car, for that matter) is usually an indicator of how much money one has. Our society has a surfeit of material things for many, but we also seem to be somewhat disconnected from each other.

We are under government rule and always seem to be complaining about what they are doing and not doing. We comment on the price hikes of food and petrol and blame that on the government too. Poor service delivery? Power outages? “Oh, this government is useless.” Well, if they are so useless, think about the question I posed earlier. Would you live in Kowloon despite its low standard of living? Would you live in a place of anarchy?

 

People usually associate the word ‘anarchy’ with chaos. But think about it: we are not exactly living peacefully, are we? Our standard of living is not rising exponentially either. The only real difference between us and Kowloon as it was years ago is that we have a ruling body and they didn’t. We only think that anarchy is bad because we are accustomed to living under government rule.

And consider this: if people start getting the idea that they can rule themselves without government…

what do you think will happen to government? And how will it react? Given various historical examples,I don’t see it going down without a fight.

  • Twitter Classic
  • Facebook Classic
bottom of page